Eduardo "Lalo" Salamanca (/ˈlɑːl ˌsæləˈmɑːŋkə/ LAH-loh SAL-ə-MAHNK, Spanish: [eˈðwaɾðo ˈlalo salaˈmaŋka]) is a fictional character and one of the main antagonists in the AMC television series Better Call Saul, a spinoff of Breaking Bad. He is portrayed by Tony Dalton, with the character being created by Peter Gould and screenwriter Gordon Smith. Lalo is introduced in the show's fourth season but was originally mentioned in dialogue from the Breaking Bad episode "Better Call Saul" that introduces Saul Goodman, though Lalo does not appear in the series.

Lalo Salamanca
Better Call Saul character
A man stands in the desert in broad daylight, looking at the camera in a slightly intimidating manner
Tony Dalton as Lalo in a promotional poster for Better Call Saul's fifth season
First appearance"Coushatta" (2018)
Last appearance"Point and Shoot" (2022)
Created byPeter Gould
Gordon Smith
Portrayed byTony Dalton
In-universe information
Full nameEduardo Salamanca
Aliases
  • Jorge de Guzmán
  • Ben
OccupationCartel operator
Relatives
HomeChihuahua, Mexico
NationalityMexican[1]

Lalo is one of many nephews of Hector Salamanca, an enforcer of Don Eladio Vuente's drug cartel. After Hector becomes paralyzed due to a stroke, Lalo arrives from Mexico to help run the family drug operation in Albuquerque; he takes a greater interest in the day-to-day details of the operation than Hector did. Because of the rivalry between Hector and his sworn enemy Gus Fring themselves, Lalo becomes determined to disrupt both Gus' legitimate business and the latter's reputation with the cartel.

Showrunners gave Dalton freedom to diverge from cartel stereotypes and portrayals of the other members of the Salamanca family. Series co-creator Vince Gilligan held himself responsible for delaying Lalo's introduction, which occurred because Gould wanted to introduce Lalo as early as season one. Unlike most other members of his family, Lalo is often charismatic and cheerful; like them, however, he can also be violent and murderous. Dalton's portrayal has been critically acclaimed, with some critics deeming Lalo to be one of the best villains on television.

Conception and development

edit

In July 2018, Tony Dalton joined Better Call Saul in the role of Lalo Salamanca,[2] first appearing in the season four episode "Coushatta".[3] The Breaking Bad second-season episode "Better Call Saul" mentions Lalo and also introduces Saul Goodman—Jimmy McGill's business name—and mentions "Ignacio" (Nacho Varga).[4] In an interview before Better Call Saul aired, Vince Gilligan said the writers had envisioned Lalo as a major character and as with Breaking Bad, they must "keep close tabs on what our characters have done in the past and make good use of it here in the present and the future".[5] Gilligan and Peter Gould, however, had difficulty deciding how to properly introduce the character, whom they considered a bogeyman around the second season of Breaking Bad but had not worked out his personality or motivations. Gilligan held himself responsible for delaying Lalo's introduction, as Gould had wanted to introduce Lalo as early as season one.[6][7] Gould realized Lalo needed to be different from the other members of the Salamanca family and a foil equal to Gus Fring.[6] He credited the show's casting directors Sherry Thomas and Sharon Bialy for selecting Dalton for the role, adding Dalton had "the charm, and the joy, and the threat" needed for the character and "all the charm of a '40s movie star".[8] Gould said Lalo was named after the composer Lalo Schifrin.[9]

 
A 1970 Chevrolet Monte Carlo, Lalo's signature vehicle.[10]

The episode "Wiedersehen", which was written by Gennifer Hutchison, further develops Lalo.[11] Hutchison said while Lalo is just as "scary" as the other Salamancas, he is "a little more circumspect about things". She said the producers wanted him to be "a little charming", in contrast to the other Salamancas, whom she felt have few qualities beyond fearsomeness.[12] Dalton said the season-five finale "Something Unforgivable" provides a breadth not seen in prior episodes. Lalo first appears as a charismatic person his extended family and cartel leaders welcome but shows a vicious, vengeful side after his family is attacked.[13] Dalton said this personality in season six differentiates him from the laid-back personality he displays in season five.[14][15] Michael Mando, who portrays Nacho, described Lalo as "a Salamanca in every way, just like Tuco and Hector had their own flavors to the erratic Salamancas".[16] Gilligan and Gould gave Dalton freedom to portray Lalo's personality as he saw fit, just as they had allowed Jonathan Banks to develop Mike Ehrmantraut during Breaking Bad,[17] though they told Dalton to think of Lalo as somewhat a "Prince of the Narcos".[15] Dalton considers Lalo to be in juxtaposition to Gus due to Lalo's laid-back attitude and "loose body language" that contrasts with Gus being constantly anxious and having a tighter body language.[15]

According to Dalton, Lalo was originally not intended to be charming; he felt the series needed someone "kind of smiling and carefree and a little bit mischievous" like Jimmy but "in the bad guy's part".[18] Dalton took inspiration from Samuel L. Jackson's character Jules Winnfield in Pulp Fiction (1994) to create a "[k]ind of this smart ass, sort of scary but kind of carefree, kind of cool guy".[18] The negative characters portrayed by Jack Nicholson also influenced Dalton's portrayal of Lalo.[15] Dalton sought to distance himself from his role in the television series Sr. Ávila, in which he played a hitman who he felt had "zero personality". Dalton instead took inspiration from Geoffrey Rush's character in Elizabeth (1998) who smiles while killing. Dalton toned down Lalo's Mexican accent because of his belief the character, given his wealth, was educated in a "good school" in the United States.[19] He chose for the character an accent he had developed while growing up around Laredo, Texas. Dalton gave Lalo an upbeat personality to show the character's normally easy-going outlook on life and to distance him from typical portrayals of cartel members as serious about their work.[13] Lalo is killed by Gus in the season-six episode "Point and Shoot". Gordon Smith said the writers considered having Mike kill Lalo but this idea was discarded to let the "biggest big bads" in the series—Gus and Lalo—confront each other.[20]

Character biography

edit
 
Tony Dalton portrays Lalo Salamanca

Arrival in Albuquerque

edit

Eduardo "Lalo" Salamanca is one of many nephews of Hector Salamanca, an enforcer of Don Eladio Vuente's drug cartel. After Hector suffers a stroke that leaves him paralyzed and unable to speak, Lalo moves from Mexico to Albuquerque to help run the Salamanca family's drug operation and takes a greater interest in day-to-day details than Hector did. Nacho Varga, Hector's subordinate, is secretly responsible for Hector's stroke and acts as a mole for Hector's rival Gus Fring, so Lalo's arrival leaves him uneasy.[21] Lalo visits Hector in the nursing home and gives him a front desk call bell he saved when Hector killed a hotelier and burned down the hotel after the hotelier disrespected him. Lalo attaches the bell to Hector's wheelchair so Hector can communicate by ringing it with his right index finger, the only body part he can move. Lalo arrives at Los Pollos Hermanos and introduces himself to Gus. Lalo thanks Gus for giving Hector first aid and paying for his care but surveils Gus' underlings to learn about their regular activities.[22]

While staking out Gus' chicken farm, Lalo observes activity related to Werner Ziegler's escape. He follows Mike Ehrmantraut as Mike tracks Werner, leading him to a Travelwire store. Mike guesses Werner is going to a hot springs resort and persuades Gus to let him retrieve Werner instead of sending hitmen. After Mike and Gus leave, Lalo enters and tries to learn what Mike knows but the clerk, Fred Whalen, refuses to tell him. Lalo kills Fred, reviews the security footage Mike saw, and sets fire to the store. Lalo calls resorts until he finds Werner; he then poses as Gus' employee and tricks Werner into revealing details about the construction of a methamphetamine lab under Gus' industrial laundry. Mike arrives at Werner's location and ends the call but realizes Lalo now has information about the construction. Mike reports to Gus, who realizes Werner will have to be killed to prevent Lalo from learning more; Mike accepts responsibility and kills Werner.[23]

Disrupting Gus' business

edit

Gus draws Lalo to a meeting by "stepping on" the Salamancas' share of the cartel's cocaine. With Juan Bolsa present, Gus tells Lalo Werner was constructing a chiller and fled after stealing cocaine. He claims he then attempted to cover for the loss by replacing the cocaine with local, inferior meth. Because the cover story explains events Lalo knows about, he outwardly accepts Gus' explanation and apology. Bolsa tells Lalo Gus enjoys Eladio's trust so Lalo should consider the matter closed. Because of Lalo's presence in Albuquerque, Gus stops work on the meth lab.[24] Lalo tells Hector he does not believe Gus' cover story; Hector confirms the cartel tolerates Gus only because he earns well.[25]

When Krazy-8 is arrested outside a Salamanca stash house, Nacho gains Lalo's trust by climbing over rooftops to sneak in and recover the drugs before police enter. Lalo is impressed and takes Nacho into his confidence. Nacho takes Jimmy to Lalo, who knows of Jimmy from Tuco. Lalo asks Jimmy to free Krazy-8 by using him to feed the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) information on Gus' dead drops. Nacho informs Gus, who accepts the loss of cash from the dead drops to protect Nacho's role as his informant. Jimmy secures Krazy-8's release and makes him a confidential informant for DEA agent Hank Schrader. Lalo congratulates Jimmy but Nacho warns him once he begins working for drug dealers, there is no turning back.[26]

While posing as a private investigator for Fred's family, Mike persuades a witness to Fred's murder to provide police with details about Lalo's car, leading to Lalo's arrest.[27] In jail under an alias, Lalo is initially denied bail and is suspicious of how the police came to pursue him, and he instructs Nacho to burn down one of Gus' restaurants. Gus realizes Lalo will continue to be a problem but decides killing him will create tension with the cartel, so Gus and Nacho again protect Nacho's role as Gus' informant by burning down the restaurant. Gus then orchestrates Lalo's release by having Mike provide Jimmy with details of Mike's investigation, which Jimmy uses to accuse police of witness tampering. The judge grants Lalo bail, which is set at $7 million cash.[28]

Lalo's cousins Leonel and Marco deliver the money to Jimmy at a remote desert location. On his return trip, gunmen stop Jimmy, take the cash, and prepare to kill him. Mike was following Jimmy for Gus and kills all but one gunman. They continue the return trip to Albuquerque with the money; when Jimmy's car breaks down, they push it off the side of the road, take the cash, and walk for two days. On the second day, they kill the remaining gunman then continue their journey to Albuquerque.[29]

Jimmy posts Lalo's bail and hides Mike's involvement by claiming he was alone and walked after his car broke down. Mike reports to Gus, who realizes Bolsa sent the gunmen in the belief he was protecting Gus' business by keeping Lalo imprisoned. Lalo prepares to return to Mexico to avoid trial but his suspicions lead him to search for Jimmy's car. Lalo confronts Jimmy and Kim Wexler at her apartment, and reveals he found it and that it had several bullet holes. Kim tells Lalo a passerby probably shot at Jimmy's car for fun and berates him for not trusting Jimmy. Lalo leaves for Mexico with Nacho.[30]

At Lalo's Chihuahua home, friends and family greet him and Nacho. Lalo introduces Nacho to Eladio, who blesses the plan for Nacho to oversee the Salamanca drug business in Lalo's absence. Gus sends assassins to Lalo's home and Nacho receives a call instructing him to leave Lalo's back gate open at 3 am. Lalo is awake at the appointed hour so Nacho sets a kitchen fire to distract him and opens the gate. Nacho flees as the assassins enter and kill most of Lalo's family and guards. Lalo kills the assassins and forces the last one alive to report his death to the middleman who arranged the attack. Lalo then realizes Nacho is missing and angrily strides away from his house.[31]

War against Gus

edit

Lalo kills a tenant who resembles him and leaves the burned body inside his home, causing police and the cartel to assume Lalo is dead. Lalo calls Hector to inform him that he is alive and intends to kill Gus in revenge for the attack. Hector indicates that Lalo will need proof of Gus' treachery that is strong enough to persuade Eladio, and Lalo realizes the proof is not in the United States, so he abandons plans to sneak back into New Mexico.[32] After Bolsa and Gus visit Hector and promise him vengeance for Lalo's supposed death, Gus realizes from Hector's demeanor that Lalo is still alive.[33] Now anticipating a revenge attack by Lalo, Gus has Mike arrange for around-the-clock guards for his home and businesses.[34] Arriving in Germany under an alias, Lalo befriends Werner's widow Margarethe, which leads him to a lucite sculpture given to Werner by his crew.[35] He uses the sculptor's label to locate Casper, whom he disables and coerces into revealing details of the project Werner was supervising.[36]

Lalo returns to Albuquerque and stakes out the laundry, intending to get video footage of the meth lab for Eladio. Lalo prepares to call Hector, but hangs up after realizing Gus has probably tapped the line. He tricks Gus by calling Hector and pretending he plans to attack Gus at his home. Mike plays a recording of the call for Gus, then diverts men to Gus' home, leaving other potential targets unguarded. Lalo arrives at Jimmy and Kim's apartment, where Howard Hamlin is confronting them about their plan to ruin his reputation. Kim implores Howard to leave but Lalo shoots Howard dead.[37]

Lalo gives Jimmy an address and general description of Gus, and tells him to go there and shoot the person he described. Jimmy persuades Lalo to send Kim instead. After Kim leaves, Lalo ties up Jimmy and tells him about the attack on his compound. Jimmy denies involvement and blames Nacho. Lalo leaves for the laundry after threatening to interrogate Jimmy upon his return. Kim is apprehended at Gus' door and Gus realizes sending Kim to his house was a diversion, so he goes to the laundry. Lalo kills Gus' guards then forces Gus to show him the unfinished lab while he videotapes it. Lalo prepares to kill Gus, but Gus cuts power to the lights and shoots towards Lalo with a gun he had earlier hidden in the lab. When he turns on the lights, Gus realizes he has fatally wounded Lalo. Mike buries Lalo and Howard beneath the floor of the lab, then tells Jimmy and Kim they will not see Lalo again.[38]

Aftermath

edit

Gus is called to Eladio's home, where Bolsa reads Hector's statement claiming Lalo survived the shootout at his house, that Gus sent the gunmen, and has since killed Lalo for real. With no proof of Lalo's initial survival, Eladio dismisses Hector's accusations.[39] In 2008, when Walter White and Jesse Pinkman kidnap Saul to coerce him into representing Badger, who has been arrested for selling meth, a terrified Saul believes Lalo sent them and says, "It wasn't me! It was Ignacio!". Saul is relieved when Walter and Jesse's confusion confirms they have no connection to Lalo.[40] When Jesse asks who Lalo is, Saul dismisses Jesse without explaining any further.[41] In 2010, Saul is still not entirely convinced Lalo died, calling him "apparently" dead during a phone call with Kim. After being informed by Saul that Mike and Gus are now also dead, Kim confesses the true nature of Howard's death to prosecutors and to Howard's widow, Cheryl. She names Lalo as Howard's killer in her affidavit, but admits to Cheryl that although Cheryl has grounds for a wrongful death lawsuit, Kim will likely not face criminal prosecution as most of the witnesses are dead and the location of Lalo's and Howard's bodies remains unknown.[42]

Reception

edit

The character Lalo Salamanca and Tony Dalton's performance have received critical acclaim; some critics deemed Lalo one of the best villains on television.[43][44] Reviewing the episode that introduces Lalo, Alan Sepinwall of Rolling Stone said Dalton "makes a solid first impression in the role" and that he hoped for "more than filling in a blank most viewers had long since forgotten existed".[45] Sepinwall called the final scene in "Bad Choice Road", in which Lalo confronts Jimmy and Kim, one of the best in the series. He praises the lead actors' performances, particularly those of Rhea Seehorn as Kim and Dalton as Lalo.[46] Steve Greene of IndieWire, after comparing Lalo to the character Anton Chigurh in the film No Country for Old Men, noted Lalo has "the unpredictability of his impulsive, petulant [cousin] combined with the faux geniality of his chicken CEO rival" and praised Dalton's performance, who he says "makes that poisonous, affected smile work, especially when it's coupled with Lalo's blatant disregard for bodily harm".[47] Brian Grubb of Uproxx wrote in his review of the season-five finale, "It is almost unreasonable how good a character Lalo is. To pull this off after five seasons of this show and the full run of Breaking Bad, to just up and introduce someone this charming and evil and perfect, is basically showing off".[48]

References

edit
  1. ^ a b c Gomez, Adrian (April 10, 2020). "Crazy charm: Tony Dalton's Lalo character takes on regular role in 'Saul' Season 5". Albuquerque Journal. Archived from the original on April 13, 2020. Retrieved April 13, 2020. He's also this Mexican narco that you've never seen before.
  2. ^ Couch, Aaron (July 19, 2018). "'Better Call Saul' Unveils Unseen 'Breaking Bad' Character at Comic-Con". The Hollywood Reporter. Archived from the original on August 6, 2018. Retrieved April 27, 2020.
  3. ^ Dominguez, Noah (August 1, 2022). "Hawkeye Actor Says Better Call Saul Helped His Character's Surprise Twist". CBR. Archived from the original on August 13, 2022. Retrieved August 11, 2024.
  4. ^ Gallagher, Caitlin (September 25, 2018). "Who Is Lalo On 'Better Call Saul'? This Character Referenced In 'Breaking Bad' Is Going To Cause Major Trouble For Nacho". Bustle. Archived from the original on March 9, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2020.
  5. ^ Tannenbaum, Rob (February 5, 2015). "Vince Gilligan Gives Us a Glimpse of Where Better Call Saul Is Headed". Wired. Archived from the original on March 9, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2020.
  6. ^ a b Sepinwall, Alan (April 20, 2020). "5 Burning Questions About the 'Better Call Saul' Season 5 Finale – Answered". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on April 21, 2020. Retrieved April 20, 2020.
  7. ^ Laib, Shawn (August 31, 2021). "Better Call Saul Confronts Its Legacy in Season 6". Den of Geek. Archived from the original on September 1, 2021. Retrieved September 3, 2021.
  8. ^ Siegel, Alan (April 21, 2020). "How They Made It: The Spectacular Fifth Season of 'Better Call Saul'". The Ringer. Archived from the original on April 22, 2020. Retrieved April 22, 2020.
  9. ^ McCaleb, Chris; Dixon, Kelley; Gould, Peter; Healy, Pat; MacLaren, Michelle; Tatlock, Alison; Palmer, Phillip W. (July 26, 2022). "610 Better Call Saul Insider" (Podcast). AMC. From 1:05:35 to 1:05:45. Archived from the original on July 30, 2022. Retrieved October 8, 2022.
  10. ^ Henderson, Paul (April 13, 2020). "The cars in Better Call Saul are perfect casting". GQ. Archived from the original on June 11, 2020. Retrieved June 11, 2020.
  11. ^ Segal, David (October 2, 2018). "'Better Call Saul' Season 4, Episode 9 Recap: For Whom the Bell Tings". The New York Times. Archived from the original on August 11, 2024. Retrieved August 11, 2024.
  12. ^ Fienberg, Daniel (October 1, 2018). "'Better Call Saul' Writer Breaks Down the "Wiedersehen" Rooftop Fight and That Famous Bell". The Hollywood Reporter. Archived from the original on March 9, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2020.
  13. ^ a b Yap, Audrey Cleo (April 21, 2020). "Tony Dalton on Unleashing Lalo in 'Better Call Saul's' Season 5 Finale". Variety. Archived from the original on April 22, 2020. Retrieved April 21, 2020.
  14. ^ ""Smiles Are Gone" Heading into the Final Season". AMC. April 30, 2020. Archived from the original on December 5, 2020. Retrieved March 3, 2021.
  15. ^ a b c d Tallerico, Brian (April 18, 2022). "The Deadly Charm of Tony Dalton". GQ. Archived from the original on April 18, 2022. Retrieved April 22, 2022.
  16. ^ Kurland, Daniel (August 21, 2018). "Better Call Saul Season 4: Nacho's Dark Path". Den of Geek. Archived from the original on March 9, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2020.
  17. ^ Fernandez, Maria Elena (April 20, 2020). "Better Call Saul's Tony Dalton Hopes That Lalo Gets a 'Worthy Death'". Vulture. Archived from the original on April 21, 2020. Retrieved April 21, 2020.
  18. ^ a b Gates, Christopher (March 9, 2020). "Actor Tony Dalton opens up about Better Call Saul – Exclusive interview". Looper.com. Archived from the original on March 16, 2020. Retrieved March 16, 2020.
  19. ^ Segal, David (April 20, 2020). "Tony Dalton Talks 'Better Call Saul': Sympathy for el Diablo". The New York Times. Archived from the original on April 21, 2020. Retrieved April 21, 2020.
  20. ^ Davids, Brian (July 13, 2022). "How Better Call Saul Writer-EP Gordon Smith Brought a 13-Year-Old Breaking Bad Story to a Close". The Hollywood Reporter. Archived from the original on July 16, 2022. Retrieved August 12, 2022.
  21. ^ "Coushatta". Better Call Saul. Season 4. Episode 8. September 24, 2018. AMC.
  22. ^ "Wiedersehen". Better Call Saul. Season 4. Episode 9. October 1, 2018. AMC.
  23. ^ "Winner". Better Call Saul. Season 4. Episode 10. October 8, 2018. AMC.
  24. ^ "Magic Man". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 1. February 23, 2020. AMC.
  25. ^ "50% Off". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 2. February 24, 2020. AMC.
  26. ^ "The Guy for This". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 3. March 2, 2020. AMC.
  27. ^ "Wexler v. Goodman". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 6. March 23, 2020. AMC.
  28. ^ "JMM". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 7. March 30, 2020. AMC.
  29. ^ "Bagman". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 8. April 6, 2020. AMC.
  30. ^ "Bad Choice Road". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 9. April 13, 2020. AMC.
  31. ^ "Something Unforgivable". Better Call Saul. Season 5. Episode 10. April 20, 2020. AMC.
  32. ^ "Wine and Roses". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 1. April 18, 2022. AMC.
  33. ^ "Carrot and Stick". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 2. April 18, 2022. AMC.
  34. ^ "Hit and Run". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 4. May 2, 2022. AMC.
  35. ^ "Black and Blue". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 5. May 9, 2022. AMC.
  36. ^ "Axe and Grind". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 6. May 16, 2022. AMC.
  37. ^ "Plan and Execution". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 7. May 23, 2022. AMC.
  38. ^ "Point and Shoot". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 8. July 11, 2022. AMC.
  39. ^ "Fun and Games". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 9. July 18, 2022. AMC.
  40. ^ "Better Call Saul". Breaking Bad. Season 2. Episode 8. April 26, 2009. AMC.
  41. ^ "Breaking Bad". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 11. August 1, 2022. AMC.
  42. ^ "Waterworks". Better Call Saul. Season 6. Episode 12. August 8, 2022. AMC.
  43. ^ Grubb, Brian (April 24, 2020). "Lalo Salamanca From 'Better Call Saul' Is The Best Villain On TV". Uproxx. Archived from the original on April 26, 2022. Retrieved May 4, 2022.
  44. ^ McCormick, Colin (July 7, 2020). "Better Call Saul: 5 Reasons Lalo Is The Best Villain In The Breaking Bad Universe (& 5 Alternatives)". Screen Rant. Archived from the original on April 14, 2022. Retrieved May 4, 2022.
  45. ^ Sepinwall, Alan (September 25, 2018). "'Better Call Saul' Recap: Let's Do It Again". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on March 10, 2020. Retrieved March 10, 2020.
  46. ^ Sepinwall, Alan (April 13, 2020). "'Better Call Saul' Recap: Welcome to the Dark Side". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on April 14, 2020. Retrieved April 14, 2020.
  47. ^ Greene, Steve (April 13, 2020). "'Better Call Saul' Review: Masterful 'Bad Choice Road' Sets Up a Season-Capping Standoff". IndieWire. Archived from the original on April 15, 2020. Retrieved April 18, 2020.
  48. ^ Grubb, Brian (April 21, 2020). "'Better Call Saul' Season Finale Truth And Lies: Kim Wexler Breaks Bad". Uproxx. Archived from the original on June 24, 2020. Retrieved August 13, 2020.
edit