Already a subscriber?
Log In
Cast | + Add Cast |
308 cast members |
Name | Episodes | Known for |
---|---|---|
Russ Harris
Narrator
|
7
|
|
J. Buzz Von Ornsteiner
Self - Analyst / Analyst
|
5
|
|
Matt Gulbranson
Sheriff / Clifford Haddix / Sheriff McGahee
|
4
|
|
Keith Kuperman
Detective / Police / Police Officer / Sheriff Officer
|
3
|
|
Jesse Robinson
Head Fireman / Jimmy Alday / Property Manager
|
3
|
|
Vince Eisenson
Neil Woodman / Tyler Williams
|
3
|
|
MauraClaire Harford
Brenda Freeman / Dolores Ross
|
2
|
|
Erin Nordseth
Maria Marino / Sally Williams
|
2
|
|
Thomas C. McKee
Bullied Kid / Ward Weaver III (age 11)
|
2
|
|
Debbie Tsamoudakis
Lori Pond / Young Jesse
|
2
|
|
Tom Gambrill
Husband #3 / Older Paul Komyatti Sr.
|
2
|
|
Karen Dadey
Brookey Lee West / Janet French
|
2
|
|
David Clayman
Self - Forensic Psychologist
|
2
|
|
Sonia Debreczeni
Christine Smith (Middle Age) / Margaret Fuss
|
2
|
|
Matthew Shea
Jason Befort / Stewart Woodman
|
2
|
|
Xavier Wolf
Eric Freeman / Young Wiley Harpe
|
2
|
|
Katherine Ramsland
Self / Self - Professor of Forensic Psychology
|
2
|
|
Brian Foreman
Detective / Doctor
|
2
|
|
Dave Ferrier
Gary Matson / Ted Stuard
|
2
|
|
Peter Chiamardas
Detective Mike Chambers / W.F. McCrotty
|
2
|
|
Meg Scanlon
Maria Aquilar / Winifred Clark
|
2
|
|
Will Steckman
John / Teen 2
|
2
|
|
Johnna Leary
Mary Stegall / Teenage Paula
|
2
|
|
Dallas White
Teenage Danny / Young Wayne
|
2
|
|
Deanna Sherman
Vicki Notaro / Young Karen
|
2
|
|
Robert Olausen
Detective / Doctor
|
2
|
|
Aaron Nelson
Derek / Young Donny Tison
|
2
|
|
Don Whatley
Nick
|
2
|
|
Jamal Alkhaldi
Duncan Meekins
|
2
|
|
Darren T. Brown
David / David Johnston
|
2
|
|
Sarah Middlemiss
Mrs. Winslow
|
2
|
|
Chaz Riddle
Detective Riddle
|
2
|
|
Alexis Barone
Young Nancy
|
2
|
|
Chris A. Wargo
Ed Bowen
|
2
|
|
Valerie Grace
Vera Woodman
|
2
|
|
Jesse Milliner
Chris Aldrich / Older Chris Aldrich
|
2
|
|
Scott Bruffey
Gary / Gary Harvill
|
2
|
|
Tom Schmitt
Young Gary Tison
|
1
|
|
Colin McHugh
Ward Weaver II
|
1
|
|
Misti Morningstar
Becky Sears
|
1
|
|
Ben Ribler
Ward Weaver III
|
1
|
|
Tracey Allyn
Megan
|
1
|
|
Jack Heffron
Ward Weaver II Age 11
|
1
|
|
Amee Walden
Gary Smock's Wife
|
1
|
|
Christina Carlos
Maria Stout
|
1
|
|
Dom DiMercurio
Store Clerk
|
1
|
|
Jodi Stapler
Dorothy Weaver
|
1
|
|
Arthur Titus
Robert Budrow Jr.
|
1
|
|
Miranda Robbins
Agatha Ward
|
1
|
|
James Matthew Poole
Vincent Taragon
|
1
|
|
Allison Naglieri
Miranda Gaddis
|
1
|
|
Elijah Lee King
Vernon
|
1
|
|
Lillie Jewell
Ashley Pond
|
1
|
|
Gabriela Kostadinova
Randi
|
1
|
|
Ricky Montano
Cellmate (Wards) informant
|
1
|
|
Adrian Fernandez
Hitchhicker
|
1
|
|
Geoffrey Greene
Public Defender
|
1
|
|
Paul H Chapman
Younger Paul Komyatti Sr.
|
1
|
|
Bonnie Webster
Crack Mom
|
1
|
|
Erin C. Davis
MaryClaire Akers
|
1
|
|
Karn Ford
Mom Post
|
1
|
|
Josh Reiter
Neighborhood Boy
|
1
|
|
Peter Muggleworth
Mikey
|
1
|
|
Will Machuca
Police officer Fishburn
|
1
|
|
Audrey Graziano
Delores Eggert
|
1
|
|
Bob Armstrong
Grandfather
|
1
|
|
Dave Fairbanks
Paul Koymatti Friend
|
1
|
|
James Davenjay
Police Officer
|
1
|
|
Stuart Orloff
Young Joe Post
|
1
|
|
Amelia Rose Bennett
Young Keri Allen
|
1
|
|
Don Anstock
Greg Hoeller
|
1
|
|
Donald Imm
Father
|
1
|
|
Allison Howard
Maryann Komyatti
|
1
|
|
Brian Slayton
Brother #1
|
1
|
|
Mollye Barrows
Self - Investigative Reporter
|
1
|
|
Kierra Spruill
Detective
|
1
|
|
Margaret Perkowski
Teenage Maryann Komyatti
|
1
|
|
Marsha Rehns
Rosemary Komyatti
|
1
|
|
Greg King
Self - Terry King's Brother
|
1
|
|
Deidre Milano
Sharon - Mother
|
1
|
|
Michael Benson
Self - Author
|
1
|
|
Mark Ziv
Young Post Brother
|
1
|
|
Steve Gustafso
Officer Hojsik
|
1
|
|
Ryan Talbot
Young Ken Allen
|
1
|
|
Wayne Ladieu
Self - School Resource Officer
|
1
|
|
John Sanderson
Self - Investigator
|
1
|
|
Richard Adams
Detective Dennis Williams
|
1
|
|
Brandon Beecher
Self - Former Ensley Fire Chief
|
1
|
|
Sara Bickler
Monica
|
1
|
|
Henry Hickerson
Adult Ken Allen
|
1
|
|
Holly Trout
Adult Keri Allen
|
1
|
|
David Rimmer
Self - Former Prosecutor
|
1
|
|
Joan Crooks
Grandmother
|
1
|
|
Samantha Fritter
Tween Keri Allen
|
1
|
|
Mike Sutton
Dr. William York
|
1
|
|
Tim Torre
Henry MacKenzie
|
1
|
|
Elliott Bales
Det. Dean Sockwell
|
1
|
|
Aaron Tone
Colonel York
|
1
|
|
Martha McConnell
Support Group Member
|
1
|
|
Janelle Schmidt
Kate Bender
|
1
|
|
Gary Ayash
Murder Victim #3
|
1
|
|
Chrislene Bright
Janice Harding
|
1
|
|
Steven Wilson Jr.
Reginald Carr
|
1
|
|
Pete Garvey
David Gilmore
|
1
|
|
Nate Nelson
Skin Head Leader
|
1
|
|
Deirdre McCullagh
Nurse
|
1
|
|
Julie Ann Garvey
Susan Gilmore
|
1
|
|
Marisa Tasheuras
Heather Muller
|
1
|
|
Graham Hooper
Jeffery Howarth
|
1
|
|
Joe Pochron
Self
|
1
|
|
Ben Church
Bender Victim
|
1
|
|
Justyn Christofel
Skinhead
|
1
|
|
Sarah Lomke
Monica Fleming
|
1
|
|
Melissa B. Robinson
Ma Bender
|
1
|
|
Cody Heuer
Aaron Sander
|
1
|
|
Rene Dechaine
Police Officer
|
1
|
|
Brett Burrier
Andrew Schrieber
|
1
|
|
Rachel Klein-Kircher
Valerie Freeman
|
1
|
|
Collin Riley
Bryan Freeman
|
1
|
|
Fred Gusoff
Dan Martin
|
1
|
|
Jack Champion
Young John Reese
|
1
|
|
Austin Zajur
Sanford Clark
|
1
|
|
Oakley Bull
Renee's Daughter
|
1
|
|
Eliza Kelley
Betty Isaacs
|
1
|
|
Anthony Hackett
George
|
1
|
|
Christopher R. Anderson
Officer Teague
|
1
|
|
Alice Bozga
Sherry
|
1
|
|
Jimmy Bacon
Stiner, Jim
|
1
|
|
Josh Kradz
Darrell Hill
|
1
|
|
Ariel Myren
Robin
|
1
|
|
Ira Grossman
Officer
|
1
|
|
Sara Torres
Renee Curtis
|
1
|
|
Laura Ruperez
Beth
|
1
|
|
Kevin Leigh
John Lyons
|
1
|
|
Todd Bobenrieth
Shanked Prisoner
|
1
|
|
George Juice Graham
Actor
|
1
|
|
David Neil Cohen
Husband #1
|
1
|
|
Reed DeLisle
Wayne
|
1
|
|
Sammy Smedley
Niki Orvin
|
1
|
|
Bianca Allaine
Margene Judge
|
1
|
|
Camryn Gulbranson
Robin's Friend
|
1
|
|
Cory Cunningham
Young Norman Johnston
|
1
|
|
Ian McCleary
Cop
|
1
|
|
Demetrius Stephens
Prisoner
|
1
|
|
Suzanna Woodhead
Paul Reese Sr's Girlfriend
|
1
|
|
Jon Musgrave
Self - Historian
|
1
|
|
Rowan Titus
Lana Sexton
|
1
|
|
Benjamin Loeh
Tommy Owens
|
1
|
|
Lawrence Derx
Sherman McCrary
|
1
|
|
Will Dinsmoor
Leslie
|
1
|
|
Tyler Rush
Christopher Lee Sexton
|
1
|
|
Jennifer Potts
Angela Dante
|
1
|
|
Cara Jaye
Convenience Store Clerk
|
1
|
|
Jason Whitaker
Jack Layne
|
1
|
|
Christopher Zash
Glennie Stiles
|
1
|
|
Anthony Papastrat
Danny McCrary
|
1
|
|
Ronald Woodhead
Robert Radford
|
1
|
|
Jennifer Brown
Sandy Stuard
|
1
|
|
Annie K. Fox
Cashier
|
1
|
|
Brendan Petak
Willie Sexton
|
1
|
|
Ian A. Wade
Ricky Mitchell
|
1
|
|
Richard Brown
Police Officer
|
1
|
|
Vivian Thompson
Lona Bishop
|
1
|
|
John Hawthorne Smith
Undercover Police Officer
|
1
|
|
J.D. Wine
Burtis Taylor
|
1
|
|
Raian Stanley
Wiley Harpe
|
1
|
|
Alexis Turrentine
Jordano's Customer
|
1
|
|
John Jarvis
Cop
|
1
|
|
Stacy Gedney
Barbara Reese
|
1
|
|
Kelsey Cooper
Betsy Roberts
|
1
|
|
Catie Carlton
Sherri Martin
|
1
|
|
Igor Bransteter
Police Officer
|
1
|
|
Patrick McCarthy
Ned Alday
|
1
|
|
Paul Alan Hogan
Gordon Stewart Northcott
|
1
|
|
Brian Lyons-Burke
Older Gary Tison
|
1
|
|
Jillian Kendrick
Tammy McCrary
|
1
|
|
Erik Young
Officer Ben Payton
|
1
|
|
Max Kelley
Young Brian Reese
|
1
|
|
Michael Kyne
Construction Worker
|
1
|
|
Sean Donegan
Young Paul Reese
|
1
|
|
JD Dan Herbert
Mr. Jenkins
|
1
|
|
Madeleine Stevens
Martha
|
1
|
|
Erik Harrison
Darrell Hill
|
1
|
|
Tom Golian
Damon Bamberg
|
1
|
|
Melissa Berkowitz
Jena Covey
|
1
|
|
Michael Colby
Jordano's Customer
|
1
|
|
Christie Jackson
Mary Alday
|
1
|
|
Matthew DeHoff
Richard Miller
|
1
|
|
Lorena Berger
Michelle Sexton
|
1
|
|
Alex Lewis
Young Bruce Jr.
|
1
|
|
Traci Dawn
Jordano's Customer
|
1
|
|
Steve Frazier
Thomas Langford
|
1
|
|
Marco Di Giuseppe
Renee's Father
|
1
|
|
Stephen Russell
Det. Fanciulli
|
1
|
|
Eddie Fitzgerald
Bag Boy
|
1
|
|
Melanie Bales
Liz McCrary
|
1
|
|
Johnny Daly
Norman Johnston
|
1
|
|
Randall Gort
Darrell Hill
|
1
|
|
Ronen Lewis
Friend
|
1
|
|
Billy Saunders Jr.
Prison Guard
|
1
|
|
Claire Coyle
Jesse Clark
|
1
|
|
A.J. Flick
Self
|
1
|
|
Ryan Wruble
Lewie Winslow
|
1
|
|
Delano Walters
Linwood Briley
|
1
|
|
Leo Rogstad
Prison Guard
|
1
|
|
Noah Sommer
Jimmy Johnston
|
1
|
|
Arthur Kraus
Charles Sexton
|
1
|
|
Laura Gepford
Desiree Flowers
|
1
|
|
Noah Peterson
Forrest Covey
|
1
|
|
Kyle Lawrence Price
Young Micajah Harpe
|
1
|
|
Zac Brightbill
Teen Paul Reese
|
1
|
|
Zachary Scruggs
Joel Good
|
1
|
|
Aaron Bryant
Raymond Carl Taylor
|
1
|
|
Megan Teresa Flynn
Terri Joe
|
1
|
|
Charlene Smith
Ginger McCrary
|
1
|
|
Marshall Shirley
Paul Reece, Sr
|
1
|
|
Anna Holmes
Jenny
|
1
|
|
Cherri Reams
Bertha Briley
|
1
|
|
Lori Titus
School Counselor
|
1
|
|
Jesse Parish III
Earl Clanton
|
1
|
|
Johnny Daly
Norman
|
1
|
|
Tim Ciskanik
Billy
|
1
|
|
Brandon Hoover
Police Officer
|
1
|
|
Barry Craig
Actor
|
1
|
|
John Cangemi
Main Prison Guard
|
1
|
|
Anthony Wruble
Nelson Wilson
|
1
|
|
Steven Foote
Bruce Jr.
|
1
|
|
Brian Slanger
Dennis Huddle
|
1
|
|
Alexander Burns
Carl
|
1
|
|
Michael Nikolich
Older Raymond Tison
|
1
|
|
Jake Taber
Jeffrey Landrigan (Child)
|
1
|
|
Jeffery M. Siperly
Chester Dyer
|
1
|
|
Allie Burrier
Leeora Looney
|
1
|
|
Loretta Burnette
Actress
|
1
|
|
Austin Burns
Paul Jr.
|
1
|
|
Alexa Kelley
Dawn Stuard
|
1
|
|
Jason M. Hamel
Cop
|
1
|
|
Steven Tyler Foote
Bruce Johnston Jr.
|
1
|
|
Erin DeCaprio
Mae Sexton
|
1
|
|
David Hammond
Truck driver
|
1
|
|
Rachel Chelsea Foster
Stefanie Petrozzino
|
1
|
|
Harvey Roberts
State Trooper
|
1
|
|
Grant Morningstar
Teenage Larry
|
1
|
|
Caleigh Anne
Laura Matusiewicz
|
1
|
|
Brenna Sherman
Young Jennifer
|
1
|
|
Maggie Toomey
Young Karen
|
1
|
|
Andrew James Bleidner
Greg Riffe
|
1
|
|
Joe Barlam
Tony
|
1
|
|
Justin Sisk
Bobby Petrozzino
|
1
|
|
Pawel Grajnert
Self
|
1
|
|
Sam McCrea
Tom Matusiewicz
|
1
|
|
Vincent Sistrunk
Lawyer
|
1
|
|
Bryson Pitts
Little Boy Larry
|
1
|
|
Natalie Cassell
LouEllen George
|
1
|
|
Debbie Hartner
Kim Lewis
|
1
|
|
Glenn Nelson
Undercover Cop
|
1
|
|
Michael Neyland
Young David
|
1
|
|
Fin McCahill
Young Chris
|
1
|
|
Sarah Scheiner
Linda Clark
|
1
|
|
Jake Kantor
Older Larry
|
1
|
|
Austin Katz
Young John
|
1
|
|
Megan Poppy
Robin Riffe
|
1
|
|
Matthew Bernard
Army Buddy #1
|
1
|
|
Chris Stinson
Michael Sears
|
1
|
|
Kaelan Denali Dickinson
Bankteller
|
1
|
|
Patrick J. O'Neal
Michael Roden
|
1
|
|
Sandra Belforte
Jake's Mom
|
1
|
|
Alex Atwood
Bill Fuss
|
1
|
|
Richard Zane
Cpl. Shriner
|
1
|
|
Chelsea Thaler
Young Mama Maria
|
1
|
|
John Posner
Young James
|
1
|
|
Andrew Gelos
Young William George Sr.
|
1
|
|
Tony Barber
Billy George
|
1
|
|
Oakley Moran
Young Joey Marino
|
1
|
|
Christopher Reed
Joey Marino
|
1
|
|
Konstantine James
Richard Penardo
|
1
|
|
Anastasia Brunk
Middle Dolores
|
1
|
|
Doug Donovan
Denny
|
1
|
|
Janet Devine Smith
Mary Jane
|
1
|
|
John A. Taylor
Delivery Room Doctor
|
1
|
|
Liliana Katz
Young Kaitlyn
|
1
|
|
Eric Cover
Gordon
|
1
|
|
Larissa Blair
Older Laura Matusiewitcz
|
1
|
|
Charlie Titus
Nancy's Son
|
1
|
|
Thomas Hydock
Young Wayne
|
1
|
|
Derek Martin
Young Neil Woodman
|
1
|
|
Bill Halbert
Assistant Detective
|
1
|
|
Gary Davis
John Collins
|
1
|
|
Jonathan Meyer
Self Lewis County Prosecutor
|
1
|
|
Eric Evans
Police officer 1
|
1
|
|
David Noffsinger
Witness
|
1
|
|
Rochelle Weisberger
Vicky
|
1
|
|
Jennifer K. Schultz
Sharon
|
1
|
|
Haley Salyer
Kay Parsons
|
1
|
|
Frank McAleavey
Loris Rowan
|
1
|
|
Katherine Riddle
Middle Maria Elena
|
1
|
|
Max Klemm
Teenage Billy George
|
1
|
|
Shawn Murphy
Detective Pat McCarthy
|
1
|
|
Peter Orvetti
Steve Homick
|
1
|
|
Steven Beverly
Investigator
|
1
|
|
Kiera Mersky
Desirée Rinker
|
1
|
|
Orlando Gonzalez
James Ray
|
1
|
|
Jesse N. Davis
Bad Guy
|
1
|
|
Heather Katz
Confidential Informant
|
1
|
|
Christine Guerra
Melody Woodman
|
1
|
|
Benjamin Paul Morris
Detective Gene Donohue
|
1
|
|
Matthew Snare
Det Brian Harris
|
1
|
|
Mitchell Cole
David George
|
1
|